Skip to main content
Design and Material Culture

Toni Rutherford

Toni Rutherford

Researcher | Writer | Maker | Educator

Since completing her BA(Hons) Fine Art at Cumbria University in 2008 Toni Rutherford has been working in education. A technical workshop instructor in secondary and higher education establishments including traditional photography, design & technology and fine art. This has given her a wealth of practical knowledge and encounters that cross many traditional specialist subject areas including photography, printmaking, ceramics, mould-making and sculpture techniques.

Her experiences have greatly informed her research into identifying and discussing material literacy, artisan making processes and techniques of objects from the renaissance to the modern. Her work with sculpture and plaster casting techniques influenced her dissertation research 'An Exploration of Armature Design within Plaster Sculpture in Nineteenth Century England'. While her work within education establishments allows her to locate areas and methods of teaching learning and practical material knowledge exchange.

Her time spent on the course signifies a new direction in Toni's career, one that brings together her practical skills and knowledge with more grounding in historical and theoretical research. One of her main focus is how to present this historical academic information to a variety of audiences using different delivery systems including exhibitions, animations and talks that utilise all of the practical creative skills she has gained being a technical instructor over the past 12 years.

Toni has delivered and participated in talks about knowledge exchange as part of the Material Histories/Virtual World symposium and as part of the V&A Friday Lates discussing the use of smart materials to create interactive displays and artworks. She created a video show piece for Different Approaches, discussing the role of material literacy in understanding how makers learn material properties, processes and technique in historical research. Her work on Digital Discomforts allowed the visualisation of group conversations between her cohort discussing accessibility of digital platforms in response to researching through a global pandemic.

Image - Interior view of fibrous plaster casting workshop of Tanner &Sons, Liverpool ca1900, V&A collection, E.1075-1989

Toni Rutherford

Tracing Practical Knowledge

Coming from a practice-based and technical background my research interests have often laid in the transfer of knowledge and craft. This course has pushed me to develop my research practices allowing me to further explore these subjects; to learn more about the practices of the past that might inform the practices of tomorrow.

Practices and knowledge transfer can be seen as a thread throughout my engagement with the course. For example while studying Moulded Leather Cases from the fifteenth century, it became clear these small unassuming leather cases held a wealth of practical knowledge. This was revealed by looking closely at the material properties of individual cases and working with conservators, to gain material and process knowledge through experimentation. A process that is lost to time and, with limited written sources, can now only be speculated based on the limited cases that have survived. I also researched how the knowledge of abstract notions, Railway Time, was transferred into society. Exploring how the change from solar to railway time was communicated and became socially impactful, even in places without a train station. The breadth of the impact from this design change is fascinating and the material culture of this change is something I look forward to researching more in the future.

This interest in knowledge transfer has culminated in my dissertation exploring armatures in plaster casts of the nineteenth century. The research deals with the attitudes and materials involved in creating the internal supports of plaster sculpture and reproductions. Exploring the influence of the French art schools and studios on the Government Schools of Design curriculums and the influence of Italian practitioners on those creating and installing plaster reproductions. This research has been greatly aided by my previous experience working with plaster casting and sculptural materials. My own background in making allows me to see the small, unseen, embodied knowledge that migrating practitioners can bring to a creative community many of which are still used in plaster casting today. The challenge of exploring and telling the stories of those unnamed practitioners and small process changes through history has been really fascinating and one I hope to continue.

The containers below give brief chapter abstracts of the dissertation research I have been engaged with, please don't hesitate to contact me if you would like to discuss the research more.

Teaching Attitudes
Teaching Attitudes — Report 1849, Great Britain Parliament House of, Reports from the Select Committee on the School of Design; (Great Britain: Great Britain Parliament House of Commons, 1849) pp xxviii
Student Occupations
Student Occupations — Students were asked to list their occupation on application forms to attend the Government Schools of Design. This information can be seen collated for a Government Report. Now allows researches to gain understanding into the industries in each of the places where a Government School of Design was established and what manufacturers it supported. Report 1843-4, Third Report of the Council of the School of Design, for the Year 1843-4, British Library, Document Supply OP-f[566].
A Collection of Casts
A Collection of Casts — This 1853 catalogue of casts shows the range casts produces by the artisan D. Brucciani for the Government Schools of Design. Report 1853, Report of the Department of Practical Art: Presented to Both Houses of Parliament by Command of Her Majesty (Great Britain: Department of Practical Art, H.M. Stationery Office, 1853)

Chapter one lays the foundation in understanding the place and perception of modelling within the ideals of the British Government, and its need to increase the taste and skills of British manufacturers by setting up Government Schools of Design. After briefly exploring the history of the Government Schools of Design the chapter is structured following Grace Lees-Maffei's Production/Consumption/Mediation model. Each section focuses on a different branch of the model and how those networks influence or impact the curriculum of the modelling classes held at the Government Schools of Design.

The Teachers, the mediators of the knowledge. By exploring the teachers backgrounds and attitudes towards the modelling classes, we can examine how mastery, or lack of knowledge of the subject area can directly impact on the engagement of the modelling classes by students. This leads into discussion of the consumers of that knowledge.

The Students, consumers of that knowledge. Information collected on students attending the Government Schools of Design for reports to parliament allow us to explore access to the modelling classes though gender, occupations and costs. This section also discusses the expectations placed upon the students by the Government Schools of Design and how the recruitment of teaching staff from student ranks produces a self-fulfilling loop of knowledge exchange.

The Artisan, producers of examples. The last section explores the collection and production of teaching examples used within the curriculum. The collection of casts was carefully curated to elevate the taste of students but this section also explores the skills and knowledge that went into producing the plaster casts by London based Italian plaster figure making firm Brucciani and Co, to explore the often hidden influence of the artisan.

Overall, this chapter examines how different networks impact the knowledge being discussed within modelling classes held by the Government Schools of Design.

Medium:

Written Thesis chapter

Size:

approx 7000 words
Armature of a Modelled Figure
Armature of a Modelled Figure — illustration of an ‘armature in action’ demonstrating the movement and stability provided for each section by the materials and binding processes. Modelling; a guide for teachers and students vol I. Lanteri (1902)pp96
Armature of a Figure cast in Plaster
Armature of a Figure cast in Plaster — Photograph of an armature placed in the front section mould of a figure. The armature run centrally up the legs with thinner supports going into the arm cavities. Casting in Plaster, Enrico Cantoni Arts and Crafts, nov 1904 pp 271

Chapter two explores learning through written resources, manuals and books on modelling published in the latter part of the nineteenth century. By exploring the written resources available and the role books played within the Government Schools of Design, further unpicking the influences and attitudes towards modelling classes by analysing the authors and audience of such books. These books will give an insight into the curriculum of a modelling class, further exploring the research question; Where did the knowledge of armature design originate and what can these written materials tell us about the evolution of modelling and plaster casting processes during the nineteenth century? By using Actor Network Theory (ANT) to elevate principles and materials to ‘actors’ used in armatures to better understand the networks involved in knowledge exchanges surrounding armatures.

Collecting and Creating Books, by placing books into the network of influence on knowledge of armature design and modelling we can gain a better understanding of where knowledge originated. The carefully curated collections of books by the Government Schools of Design created a library that was largely European in origin, which both broadened and narrowed the perspectives available to students. This section also examines who wrote English instruction books on modelling and casting in plaster, their backgrounds and connections to already established educational systems. Their intended audiences bring up questions of how modelling classes were gendered in the nineteenth century.

Modelling Figures, the role of anatomy can also be placed within the network as it becomes a key idea of how to structure an armature for modelling purposes. This chapter also examines the materials used to create armatures for modelling sculptures, their properties and placements within the armature constructions in both large and small scale sculpture.

Casting Figures, in comparison to the armatures use for modelling sculptures, those used for casting sculptures follow a different set of rules and material use. This section discusses the rules that govern the placement of the armature in a mould prior to casting, and how the placement, material choices and treatments can affect the survival of a plaster cast sculpture over time.

This chapter explores the different information available to the public, its accessiblity and intention. It discusses the details of what may have been taught to students attending the modelling classes at the Government Schools of Design.

Medium:

Written thesis chapter

Size:

approx 6500 words
Apprentice Pillar and South East Corner of Roslyn Chapel
Apprentice Pillar and South East Corner of Roslyn Chapel — Photograph commissioned by the Department of Science and Art showing the Apprentice Pillar and South- East corner of Roslyn Chapel Repro.1871-59. Gives a clear viewing of the pillar, and roof section while indicating large windows on both the south and east walls. Victoria and Albert Museum, Prints, Drawing and Paintings Collection PH.391-1902
Trajan's Column, Internal View
Trajan's Column, Internal View — Photograph of the internal view of the Trajan’s Column plaster cast reproduction exhibited in the V&A Cast Courts. The brick and wooden internal structure visible. The internal room was opened up to visitors after the refurbishment of the Cast Courts at Victoria and Albert Museum. Image authors own 2020

Chapter Three, focused on the praxis of armature design in evolving the collections of the examples held by the Government Schools of Design into the South Kensington Museum, during the mid-nineteenth century. Using different case studies, this chapter explored the different practitioners and collaborations that contributed to the plaster casting field by creating large scale plaster reproductions for the Cast Courts at South Kensington Museum. Using Actor Network Theory again to explore the different influences driving the development of displaying plaster cast examples during the nineteenth century.

Monumental Plaster Reproductions on the design of the Cast Courts of South Kensington Museum, with a focus on the installation and support structures of Trajan’s Column and the role of Royal Engineers in the building and installing of the Cast Courts.

Creation and Installation of the Apprentice Pillar show a teaching and learning dynamic between London plaster cast practitioner Giovanni Franchi, and Royal Engineers based at South Kensington Museum. This section discusses the influence of the Franchi on the development of the cast courts, exploring the skills of the artisans and how that influence can be traced by exploring the examples in the Cast Courts.

Overall this chapter looks beyond the surface of the monumental cast examples found at the Victoria and Albert Museum, questioning the making and installation processes that are often hidden from public view.

Medium:

Written thesis chapter

Size:

approx 3000 words

Joan Jordan Bequest V&A Scholarship

Joan Jordan studied at the Study Centre for Fine and Decorative Arts at the V&A. She was unable to 'afford the whole course', she was later asked to teach at the Wallace Collection on its history, French Furniture and Sevres porcelain as well as the Education Department at the V&A on Meissen porcelain. It was her wish that her bequest to the V&A was used as a scholarship to help someone else 'study Fine and Decorative Arts who would otherwise not be able to afford to do this', this bequest has given me the chance to study on the MA History of Design course run jointly by the V&A and RCA.